Christmas is the perfect time to gather around and play “Would You Rather.” Whether you’re waiting for dinner to be ready, sitting around the tree after opening presents, or hosting a holiday party, these festive questions will keep everyone talking and laughing.
We put together 100 Christmas-themed questions that cover everything from Santa debates to holiday food dilemmas. Pick a category or go through them all – your holiday crowd will thank you.
How to play “Would You Rather”
The rules are dead simple. One person reads a question with two options, and everyone else has to pick one. No “both” and no “neither” – you have to commit to your choice.
The fun part is explaining why you picked what you picked. That’s where the real conversations (and arguments) happen. Go around the table so everyone gets a turn, and don’t be afraid to dig into the reasoning behind someone’s answer.
For Christmas gatherings, try mixing up the categories. Start with the family-friendly ones during dinner, then switch to the harder or funnier ones once the kids are in bed.
Play “Would You Rather” online
Don’t want to read questions off a screen? Play our online version instead – hundreds of questions across tons of categories, including holiday-themed ones.
Christmas Would You Rather questions for families
These questions work for all ages. Pull them out during Christmas dinner or while decorating the tree – they’re clean, festive, and guaranteed to spark some debate.
1. Would you rather open all your presents on Christmas Eve or wait until Christmas morning but get double the gifts?
Patience has never been tested like this.
2. Would you rather have snow every single Christmas or spend every Christmas on a tropical beach?
White Christmas romantics vs. flip-flop holiday lovers – pick your side.
3. Would you rather only be able to eat candy canes for a week or only drink hot chocolate for a week?
Your dentist is already nervous.
4. Would you rather have Rudolph’s glowing red nose or pointy elf ears for all of December?
One lights up the room, the other gives you serious fantasy character energy.
5. Would you rather decorate the world’s tallest Christmas tree or build the world’s biggest snowman?
Both require a very tall ladder.
6. Would you rather get caught under the mistletoe with your school teacher or your boss?
Awkward either way, but one is definitely worse.
7. Would you rather have a real reindeer as a pet or a penguin that wears a tiny Santa hat?
One is majestic, the other is adorable. Tough call.
8. Would you rather sing Christmas carols door to door every night in December or wear a full Santa suit to work/school every day?
Ho ho hope you like attention.
9. Would you rather only receive socks as gifts for the rest of your life or never receive a gift again but get to give the perfect gift to everyone?
The sock drawer debate of the century.
10. Would you rather live in a gingerbread house for a month or in an igloo for a month?
One smells amazing but might attract ants. The other is just cold.
11. Would you rather have your house covered in Christmas lights year-round or play Christmas music in every room 24/7 all December?
Your neighbors will have opinions about both.
12. Would you rather be able to make it snow on command or instantly wrap any gift perfectly?
One is magical, the other is actually useful.
13. Would you rather eat only fruitcake for every meal on Christmas Day or only eat Brussels sprouts?
The two most divisive foods on the holiday table.
14. Would you rather meet the real Santa Claus or meet your favorite celebrity dressed as Santa?
One brings presents, the other brings selfies.
15. Would you rather fly in Santa’s sleigh on Christmas Eve or ride the Polar Express to the North Pole?
Two legendary Christmas rides – only one seat available.
16. Would you rather have a Christmas tree that decorates itself or a fireplace that never goes out all winter?
Technology vs. cozy tradition.
17. Would you rather know what every gift is before you open it or always be completely surprised?
Some people shake the box. Others cover their eyes.
18. Would you rather spend Christmas at Hogwarts or in Whoville?
Magic spells or a heart that grows three sizes – your move.
19. Would you rather be the star on top of the Christmas tree or the angel?
Either way, you’re looking down on everyone.
20. Would you rather have a snowball fight with your family every Christmas morning or build a snow fort together?
Offense or defense?
21. Would you rather help Santa deliver all the presents in one night or help Mrs. Claus bake cookies for a year?
Speed vs. deliciousness.
22. Would you rather your Christmas dinner be cooked by a celebrity chef or your grandma?
Michelin stars can’t compete with grandma’s secret recipe. Or can they?
23. Would you rather wear an ugly Christmas sweater every day in December or a pair of jingle bell shoes?
One is a fashion statement, the other announces your arrival.
24. Would you rather have a pet that could wrap presents with its paws or a pet that could sing carols?
Either way, you’re going viral.
25. Would you rather be trapped in a snow globe or inside a Christmas card?
A tiny world of swirling snow or a flat, glittery existence?
Funny Christmas Would You Rather questions
Time to bring out the laughs. These questions are silly, absurd, and perfect for getting the whole room cracking up during your holiday get-together.
1. Would you rather have tinsel for hair or Christmas lights for fingers?
One sparkles, the other actually lights up the room.
2. Would you rather accidentally call your teacher “Santa” for a whole month or accidentally call your mom by the wrong name at Christmas dinner?
Both will haunt you well into the New Year.
3. Would you rather have hiccups during the entire Christmas dinner or sneeze every time someone says “Merry Christmas”?
Pass the gravy – hic – please.
4. Would you rather shrink to the size of an elf for Christmas Day or have candy canes for legs?
Small but nimble, or tall but delicious?
5. Would you rather have a Christmas tree that insults your ornament choices or a snowman that follows you around and critiques your outfit?
“Really? That ornament? On MY branch?”
6. Would you rather only speak in Christmas song lyrics for a day or have to rhyme everything you say like a Christmas poem?
“Let it snow, let it snow, can you pass the remote though?”
7. Would you rather have your laugh replaced with Santa’s “Ho ho ho” or have jingle bells play every time you walk?
Stealth mode: permanently off.
8. Would you rather slip on ice in front of your entire family or get your tongue stuck to a frozen pole?
Both make great stories at next year’s Christmas party.
9. Would you rather accidentally eat a whole plate of dog treats that look like Christmas cookies or drink eggnog that’s been sitting out for three days?
One is embarrassing, the other is dangerous.
10. Would you rather have a reindeer that refuses to fly or an elf that refuses to make toys?
Lazy coworkers come in all shapes and sizes.
11. Would you rather get stuck in a chimney like Santa or get tangled in Christmas lights for an hour?
Your family will be taking photos either way.
12. Would you rather have a snowman come to life and raid your fridge or have your Christmas tree start walking around the house?
Frosty is hungry, and that tree has places to be.
13. Would you rather burp “Jingle Bells” after every meal in December or fart glitter?
One is a party trick, the other is… also a party trick, honestly.
14. Would you rather have a gingerbread man that runs away every time you try to eat it or a candy cane that screams when you lick it?
Christmas snacks just got way more stressful.
15. Would you rather wear a blinking Rudolph nose to every meeting or have antlers that honk when someone touches them?
Professional image: destroyed.
16. Would you rather have your Christmas stocking filled with gravy or your shoes filled with cranberry sauce?
Wet socks either way.
17. Would you rather have a Christmas turkey that talks back when you try to carve it or a pudding that sings opera?
Dinner entertainment just got weird.
18. Would you rather wake up on Christmas morning to find you’ve turned into a nutcracker or a gingerbread person?
Wooden jaw or frosting skin – what a choice.
19. Would you rather have a Santa hat permanently attached to your head or mistletoe that floats above you everywhere you go?
One is mildly annoying, the other is socially dangerous.
20. Would you rather have to wrap every gift with your feet or unwrap every gift with oven mitts on?
Fine motor skills: not required.
21. Would you rather sneeze tinsel or cry eggnog?
The most festive allergies you’ll ever have.
22. Would you rather ride a shopping cart through a packed mall on Christmas Eve or slide down a frozen escalator on a sled?
Mall security is already on their way.
23. Would you rather have your Christmas photo card go viral for the wrong reasons or accidentally send your wish list to your entire contacts list?
Public humiliation: holiday edition.
24. Would you rather eat an ornament-shaped cake that tastes like cardboard or a cardboard box that tastes like the best Christmas cake ever?
Your brain and your taste buds will be very confused.
25. Would you rather have Buddy the Elf’s enthusiasm for 24 hours or the Grinch’s strength for 24 hours?
“I love smiling! Smiling’s my favorite!” vs. lifting a sleigh full of presents over your head.
Christmas Would You Rather questions for parties
Hosting a holiday bash? These questions are built for groups. They’ll get people debating, laughing, and maybe even switching sides mid-argument.
1. Would you rather attend a Christmas party where everyone has to come in pajamas or one where everyone has to dress in formal wear?
Cozy vibes or black-tie elegance – set the dress code.
2. Would you rather be in charge of the Christmas playlist or the Christmas menu?
The DJ or the chef – both hold serious power.
3. Would you rather play Secret Santa with a $5 budget or a $500 budget?
Creativity vs. extravagance. The cheap gifts are usually funnier.
4. Would you rather do Christmas karaoke in front of everyone or a holiday dance-off?
Step up to the mic or the dance floor – no hiding.
5. Would you rather be stuck at a party where the only food is fruitcake or the only drink is warm milk?
The ultimate test of holiday endurance.
6. Would you rather have the power to make any party instantly festive or the ability to end any awkward family conversation?
Decorations on demand or an escape button for weird uncle talks.
7. Would you rather play charades with only Christmas movies or only Christmas songs?
Acting out “Die Hard” is going to be interesting.
8. Would you rather host Christmas dinner for 50 people or attend 50 different Christmas parties in December?
Cook once for a crowd or be perpetually social all month.
9. Would you rather be the person who always gives the best gift or the person who always throws the best party?
Gift legend or party legend – you can’t be both.
10. Would you rather have an unlimited budget for Christmas decorations or unlimited budget for Christmas food?
Martha Stewart or Gordon Ramsay – who’s your spirit guide?
11. Would you rather do a White Elephant gift exchange where everyone brings something weird from their house or one where everyone brings homemade gifts?
Grandma’s old lamp vs. someone’s questionable pottery skills.
12. Would you rather attend a Christmas party at a haunted mansion or one on a boat in the middle of a lake?
Spooky Christmas or seasick Christmas – pick your adventure.
13. Would you rather have a party where everyone must speak in a British accent or one where everyone must speak in rhymes?
“Jolly good, pass the pudding!” or “Here’s the cheese, if you please.”
14. Would you rather win the ugly Christmas sweater contest or the Christmas cookie decorating contest?
Fashion disaster glory or culinary bragging rights.
15. Would you rather have a snowball fight tournament at the party or a gingerbread house building competition?
Athletic or artistic – choose your battlefield.
16. Would you rather attend a Christmas party where all the games are trivia-based or all physical challenges?
Brain power or muscle power.
17. Would you rather be the last one standing at the office Christmas party or the first one to leave?
Legendary stamina or mysterious departure – both have their appeal.
18. Would you rather have a Christmas party in a hot tub in the snow or by a fireplace in a cabin?
Both sound pretty great, honestly.
19. Would you rather have a live band playing only Christmas music at your party or a DJ who plays everything except Christmas music?
Full festive or festive-free zone.
20. Would you rather do a Christmas escape room or a Christmas scavenger hunt?
Solve puzzles under pressure or race around finding clues.
21. Would you rather have a holiday party where dessert is the only course or one where appetizers are the only course?
Sugar rush or savory spread.
22. Would you rather attend a Christmas masquerade ball or a Christmas costume party?
Elegant mystery or full-on Frosty the Snowman outfit.
23. Would you rather have a party with the most elaborate decorations ever or one with the best food you’ve ever tasted?
Eyes or stomach – which one wins?
24. Would you rather bring your worst dish to a potluck or have to eat everyone else’s worst dish?
Serve shame or eat shame.
25. Would you rather have a surprise celebrity guest at your Christmas party or a surprise visit from Santa himself?
Star power or pure childhood magic.
Hard Christmas Would You Rather questions
Ready for some genuinely tough choices? These questions will make you pause, think, and maybe even change your mind halfway through your answer.
1. Would you rather give up receiving Christmas gifts forever or give up giving them?
The joy of getting vs. the joy of giving – which matters more to you?
2. Would you rather spend every Christmas alone in a beautiful cabin or at a crowded family gathering that always ends in an argument?
Peace and solitude or chaotic love?
3. Would you rather lose all your childhood Christmas memories or never make new Christmas memories again?
The past or the future – a genuinely painful choice.
4. Would you rather have Christmas every month but it loses its magic or only once every five years but it feels incredible every time?
Frequency vs. intensity.
5. Would you rather relive your best Christmas ever on repeat or get a glimpse of your best future Christmas?
Nostalgia or anticipation – both are powerful.
6. Would you rather always know what you’re getting for Christmas or never know and sometimes be disappointed?
Certainty vs. the thrill of surprise.
7. Would you rather spend Christmas in a country that doesn’t celebrate it or celebrate a holiday you’ve never heard of instead?
Cultural adventure or total mystery.
8. Would you rather have the perfect Christmas Day but terrible weather or terrible Christmas Day but perfect weather?
Sunshine can’t fix a bad party, but can a good party survive a blizzard?
9. Would you rather forgive someone who hurt you every Christmas or hold onto one grudge forever?
The holidays have a way of putting relationships under a microscope.
10. Would you rather give up Christmas movies forever or Christmas music forever?
No more “Home Alone” or no more “All I Want for Christmas Is You” – both hurt.
11. Would you rather have to buy everyone a gift but go into debt or set a strict budget and risk disappointing someone?
Financial stress vs. emotional guilt – welcome to adult Christmas.
12. Would you rather always host Christmas and do all the work or always be a guest and never have control over the plans?
Master of the kitchen or at the mercy of someone else’s cooking.
13. Would you rather spend Christmas helping strangers in need or at home with your family?
Your heart says both, but you can only choose one.
14. Would you rather have a Christmas where everything goes perfectly but it doesn’t feel special or one where everything goes wrong but you laugh about it for years?
Perfection or a great story?
15. Would you rather tell a child Santa isn’t real or keep the lie going even when they’re starting to figure it out?
Honesty or magic – the eternal parenting dilemma.
16. Would you rather have to make every single gift by hand or shop for every gift on Christmas Eve?
Months of crafting or one day of pure panic.
17. Would you rather celebrate Christmas the exact same way every year or completely reinvent it each time?
Tradition is comforting, but change keeps things fresh.
18. Would you rather have a Christmas with no technology or no decorations?
Unplugged holidays or a bare, undecorated house.
19. Would you rather skip Christmas entirely this year or celebrate it twice but it’s half as special each time?
All or nothing vs. diluted magic.
20. Would you rather spend $1,000 on one meaningful gift for one person or $10 on gifts for 100 people?
Depth or breadth?
21. Would you rather be the family member who always brings everyone together or the one who everyone wants to sit next to at dinner?
The organizer or the favorite.
22. Would you rather your kids remember Christmas for the expensive gifts or for the time you spent together?
Easy to answer in theory. Harder in practice.
23. Would you rather travel across the world to see family for Christmas or have them all come to you?
Miles of airports or a full house – both come at a cost.
24. Would you rather end a family tradition that no one enjoys anymore or keep it going because it meant something once?
Letting go is hard, even when the tradition involves your aunt’s terrible casserole.
25. Would you rather have one more Christmas with someone you’ve lost or give someone else the best Christmas of their life?
This one might need a moment.
Love seasonal fun? Try our Halloween Would You Rather for spooky vibes, Thanksgiving Would You Rather for the dinner table, or Valentine’s Day Would You Rather for February. For family-friendly options, check out Would You Rather for family.
Want even more questions to keep the holiday fun going all season? Check out our full collection of “Would You Rather” questions for every occasion, mood, and group size.
